1. Education

Discuss in my forum

'Carson McCullers: Complete Novels' Review

About.com Rating 4.5 Star Rating
User Rating 5 Star Rating (1 Review) Write a review

By , About.com Guide

Carson McCullers: Complete Novels

Carson McCullers: Complete Novels

Library of America
"The Member of the Wedding"

In "The Member of the Wedding," McCullers focuses again on a young, motherless girl, who is in the midst of growing up. The work had started out as a short story; the novel-length version was completed in 1945.

With war in the background, Frankie makes her way in the world. "She wanted to be a boy," McCullers explains. She wanted to go to war. "She thought about flying aeroplanes and winning gold medals for bravery." Then, a real prospect arises. Frankie's brother is getting married, and she believes she will go to live with him--with a new name and new existence. It's her one dream. Bernice tries to explain the importance of a name: "You have a name and one thing after another happens to you, and you behave in various ways and do things, so that soon the name begins to have meaning."

Really the story is about Frankie's great escape. She talks about it, plans for it, even tries to run away... But, as Bernice tells Frankie: "We all of us are somehow caught. We are born this way or that way and we don't know why. But we are caught anyhow."

"The Clock Without Hands"

It is perhaps most appropriate that McCullers writes about death in her final novel. "Clock Without Hands" centers around a terminally ill druggist, J.T. Malone, as he comes to terms with death--the absence of life. As McCullers writes in the opening line of the novel, "Death is always the same, but each man dies in his own way."

How does one realize the full impact of death? How does a person listen as other people go on with life, realizing that life is precious, so short, and also so little appreciated? Malone is restless, as his body begins to fade. He reaches out and touches an object: a lamppost or a brick wall. He realizes, "The lamppost, the wall, the tree would exist when he was dead and the thought was loathsome to him."

In those moments, how could life or death, or anything really make sense, as he "blundered among a world of incongruities in which there was no order of conceivable design"? Even in the confusion, some of McCullers most constant themes return: the need for love, and the gravitation toward hatred.

As death grows nearer, he doesn't know what he loves or hates, as the terror chokes him: "The terror questioned what would happen in those months--how long? that glared upon his numbered days. He was a man watching a clock without hands." He waits for the design to emerge, until the struggle and fear ceases. It is the end.

User Reviews

 5 out of 5
the heart is a lonely hunter, Member ritafdorn

comprehensive and touching novel about many levels of life: teenage issues of poverty, a disabled parent, a cold parent, sexual exploration, and financial limitations. mick's mom tries very hard to kill her daughter's spirit in the name of facing reality. john singer offers mick a challenge and the refuge he seems to provide for everyone who knows him. she rises to the occasion beautifully when she ""explains"" music to him, a deaf-mute. the novel ends on a disappointing note when singer, the seeming hero, takes his life after learning of the death of his long time buddy; apparently singer felt that his deaf-mute friend, whom he mentored, was more of a soul. mate than any of the ""normal"" people in his life/ singer left a permanent and positive impacy on mick. the title is apt, referring to our singular attempts to follow our hearts and hunt down what has meaning for us, as singer did and as mick did. gentle but powerful. very profound.

Write a review

5 out of 7 people found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes | No

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.